Repair or Replacement: Which One Do I Need?

Whether to repair or replace your roof is a classic question that most homeowners have to deal with at some point. Sometimes it’s not so clear which option you should go with. For your home, you should be careful because these decisions can cost quite a bit of money sometimes. According to Choice Home Warranty, the average spending on home improvement per year is somewhere between 1% and 4%. That’s a couple of thousand dollars alone for a house that’s valued in the $200,000 range.

Here are some things to consider regarding repairing or replacing your residential roof.

When Repairs Are Best

Repairs are appropriate when the issue is distinct, can be fixed, isn’t recurring, and won’t cost more than replacement. For example, if the flashing around your chimney has a small gap in it, and roof inspectors find no other problems, then repairing the flashing is appropriate. If the flashing was half torn away by a falling branch in a storm, though, repair might not be enough if it’s too damaged.

When Replacement Is Better

Replacement is better when the cost of replacing is less than the cost of repairing, when the item simply can’t be repaired, or if the problem keeps occurring despite repairs. If you have a very old roof, the cost to repair it may be wasted if it’s truly in bad shape and keeps breaking down in different ways. Then, you’d want to just get a new roof.

As another example, let’s say your area has been ravaged by a big storm. Storm damage may have ripped off a majority of the shingles and damaged the underlayer. Replacing the roof would be better in this scenario, as the parts and labor needed to fix everything would be just as expensive and time-consuming.

If you think you need to replace a shingle roof, call experienced and qualified roofing contractors to get a professional opinion. Don’t be surprised if what you thought was a repair really needs to be a replacement or vice versa. To replace a shingle roof would require a lot of work, but depending on the condition, that may be the most efficient option. If you need to replace a shingle roof, contact ROOFWORKS today!

Damaged Roofing Shingle

Shingle Repair Checklist: What Roofers Inspect on Every Job

Understanding what professional roofers inspect during a shingle repair job can help ease concerns and provide valuable insight.

Home with New Gutters Installed

3 Essential Gutter Installation Steps For Longevity

A well-planned gutter installation supports long-term performance, especially during heavy rainfall and seasonal storms.

Ridge Cap Vent Installed on Asphalt Shingle Roof

Hidden Problems a Home Roof Inspection Can Reveal

Scheduling a routine home roof inspection is one of the most effective ways to protect long-term investment value.

Ice on Roof and Gutters

Three Gutter Mistakes Costing You Money

When gutters fail, water can back up under shingles, soak fascia boards, and place constant moisture stress on roof edges.

Roof with a Missing Shingle

3 Warning Signs Your Roof Needs Replacement

The tricky part is knowing when a simple repair is enough and when you’re dealing with a roof in need of replacement.

Roofers Working on Asphalt Shingle Roof

The Lifespan of Home Roofs: What Homeowners Should Know

Understanding the lifespan of your roof and regular maintenance requirements is crucial for determining when you may need a new roof.

Home with New Asphalt Shingle Roofing

Guide to Understanding Your Roof’s Life Span

In this guide, we explore the factors that contribute to the life span of a roof, how you can maximize it, and the typical duration you can expect.

Little Girl Sitting By Windows

Unlocking Energy Savings: The Role of Windows in Climate Control

Not only do windows contribute to the aesthetic appeal of a building but they also play a vital role in its energy efficiency.

Damaged Asphalt Shingle Roof

Choosing the Right Shingle Replacement Material for Projects

Selecting the right shingle material is a critical decision. Explore some popular options to guide your next shingle replacement project.

Home with Beautiful Professional Siding

How Professional Siding Adds Value to Your Home

In the quest for increasing the value of your home, few upgrades offer as substantial a return on investment as professional siding.

Video Demonstration

Check out this cool high speed video of a roof replacement courtesy of our awesome customer.
View Larger >

Shingle Visualizer


Browse an extensive variety of shingle styles and colors with this interactive shingle visualizer.
Browse >